Saturday, July 20, 2013

Realizing The Positives of Deception During Research

One positive example of the effects of this research can have on young children and families happened have occurred at the school where I where I am employed in Illinois, in the year 2009. I noticed a student refusing to go to class due to personal issues that caused him, to be embarrassed by other students. The students would talk bad about the way he smelled which made him dislike school. The principal allowed this child to walk around and skip classes daily. The teachers did not care enough to report issues that were visible. This young man, age 12, had developed a great relationship with me because he knew that I cared about the overall outcome of his academics as well as his personal interests. My gut wouldn’t let this situation ride. I began to research his family’s history and found out that there were sexual predators in his family. I could not share the knowledge I had gained because I was afraid that if I told him that he would close up and not share any information. After I figured that he was being sexually abused, I got permission from my principal to interview him to find out any facts that would help my thoughts of abuse. I opened the interview by asking him if there was anything that was bothering him that causes him not to want to attend his classes. I could tell from his body language that it was more to this problem. I began to tell him that anything that he shared with me would not leave the room, although I knew better because I am a mandated reporter. The child was resilient to opening up to me, I felt it. I thought quick and grabbed his hands and told him that I had been through what he is going through, although what I said was fabricated. This was the only way that I could get him to be honest with me. I told him that it happened to me as a child and I was doing the same things that he was doing- acting out. I said that I was younger than he was when it happened. I then asked him if this was happening to him, reassuring him that I would not share this information and that I only wanted to help him cope with his issue. He told me that he was being raped by his older brother and his uncle which was his mothers brother. I knew that my gut was right. He shared with me that this had been going on every since he was five . Again, as a mandated reporter, I had no choice but to help the child. I told my principal my findings and we called the Department of Children and Family Services of Illinois. Yes, I felt bad for telling the child that I would not share the information. I manipulated my words to grasp my findings, but I knew what was more important. The Department Of Children and Family Services found this allegation to be true. I feared that I had lost my relationship with that child because I deceived him to get the information that I needed to help him. I was touched when he hugged me when he saw me again, after he was removed from his mother that knew about this abuse. The uncle and brother are still in jail to this day. It has been almost a four years and we still have a great relationship. He is now in school, and he loves young ladies. He even has a few young ladies that he visits often. I was frustrated that my colleagues did not care enough to step in and help the child. I know that I have a place in helping children of all ages, but I prefer to be in Early Childhood Education. I want to be a part of helping to shape young children’s overall outcomes, as I offer passion, dedication and love for them. We have to care enough to step in and help to stir the needed changes to the field.

5 comments:

  1. I am glad you were able to recognize the signs of abuse, as a mandated reporter it is important that anyone who workes with children is able to do that. I am more than a little shocked with the way you approached the child and solicited the information, I personally consider it to be a major ethics violation and in my program would be grounds for dismissal.. I think we should all be aware of the sensitive process of investigating child abuse and leave it up to trained professionals with the Child Protection Services. All of our mandated reporter staff are trained to know that we are not investigators, we are reporters. If we suspect abuse or neglect we are to immediately report it to CPS and let them investigate. There are many reasons for this, not the least of which is the possibility for ruining a legal case by influencing the memories of the victim by conducting our own interview; and the risks of harm to the child by making false promises and misleading them. I know your heart was in the right place, but I am honestly very upset that the school leadership allowed you to conduct the meeting with the child. Maybe it could be a learning experience and an opportunity to review your schools mandated reporting guidelines and code of professional ethics to make sure future abuse cases are handled properly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I understand your frustration, but in the area that I work, there are hardly any professionals that would have even cared to understand his problem. You have to understand that children at this age that endure a lot of trauma, will not be honest with strange faces. Furthermore, as a intern counselor at that time, I had every right to follow my gut and help the child. My leader was very happy when the child was removed from harm. I do not know where you work, or what type of facility you run, but I think that you are being a bit bias. Those are your thoughts, and as a colleague, I can respect them. The big picture is that the child is out of harms way and if I did not intervene he provably would not have gotten away from this situation. I do not understand why you would fire an employee after they have helped remove a child from such harm. I actually have a heart for lost challenging children, and as I mentioned, our relationship is wonderful. I thank God for giving me the gift to reach challenging children as I stand strong on advocating for them and their well-being.
    As far as The Department of Children and Family Services in Illinois goes, they were also happy that I had enough heart to dig deep in the situation. When you work in a community where young children are told by their parents not to ever repeat what goes on in their
    home, and children are being abused which affects their development, as a professional, I am happy that the child opened up to me because I know that he would not have shared this with anyone else? Sorry, in this case, I could not leave it up to others. I believe that leaving it up to others is one of the biggest gaps in this field. I'm sorry that I cared.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am sorry if my post sounded harsh, it just raised a lot of red flags based on my program (Early Head Start and Head Start) policies and the trainings I have had as a mandated reporter. I get that working with older kids is different, and different states have different laws regarding mandated reporting. I reacted based on my training and experience. I stated that it would be grounds for dismissal because in my program it is very clearly against policy to conduct our own interviews or investigations with any child. If we suspect abuse, all interviews must be carried out by Child Protective Services with a Police detective or representative present, and only after an official report has been made, no exceptions. As I mentioned, there is a great risk of tainting a child's memory of abuse or influencing them unintentionally, and this can and has led to charges being dropped against abusers in the community where I work. I hope I didn't offed you, this is just an area where experience has shown me that we all need to be very careful about how we proceed. I am glad that you shared your story and that we can discuss our different experiences.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We are suppose to learn from each other. It is unfortunate that states have different laws and guidelines. I am happy to know that you value young children and their development.
      Thanks for your view. I've learned how your state operates with research. No pun intended.

      Delete
    2. Here are the guidelines for talking with children from www.childwelfare.gov, our program uses these as a foundation for our mandated reporting policies. It is on pg. 30 just in case it doesn't link directly. https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubs/usermanuals/educator/educator.pdf

      Delete